210-651-0303
Exercise is a critical part of losing weight and maintaining a healthy weight. How we fuel our bodies for exercise, however, has been a point of debate. Some resources say you must eat a full meal before a workout so your body has energy. Others say you should work out fasted so you burn your stored energy.
There is actually a lot of research about this topic and the answer is… it depends. Your goals, time of day for exercise, level of intensity, and length of exercise all need to be taken into account.
*Short-term studies show more fat burning with cardio exercises done in a fasting state. This is because you do not have energy available from a recent meal, so your body is forced to burn fat for fuel for the exercise. But when looking at weeks of fasted vs fed cardio, changes in weight and fat mass are essentially the same if the person is eating the same amount of calories.
*Larger meta-analyses and reviews agree that total body fat loss long-term is not impacted by whether or not you eat before exercising or not, as long as the total calories and protein are the same. This means you don’t eat an additional meal before a workout – you just time your workout to be after a meal you would have eaten anyway.
*For strength training, research finds that there is similar muscle growth and strength improvement in fasted and fed groups. There is a slight edge toward having a meal before exercising for maximal strength and muscle growth in some studies because you have ample fuel to maximize your workout.
*The American College of Sports Medicine and sports nutrition guidance generally emphasize having available carbohydrates and protein before training to support performance and adaptation, especially for longer or more intense workouts.
* For workouts 20-45 min in duration, fasting is the better way to go. You don’t need energy for sustained exercise, and you will burn a higher percentage of fat because you don’t have available energy from a meal.
*For longer workouts (over 45 minutes), working out in a fed state may fuel your endurance better and enable you to workout longer without running out of energy.
* High intensity training (HIIT or heavy lifting) may require eating in a fed state because your body will have readily available fuel to maximize your performance. Even though you may burn less fat during the workout itself, you may burn more calories overall if you lift heavier, complete more reps, push harder in intervals, maintain speed or power for longer, etc.
*High intensity exercise increases cortisol release and can lead to muscle breakdown, which increases your need for amino acids. Eating before training can preserve muscle mass and support better recovery and adaptation. This is especially important if you are currently losing weight and want to maintain muscle mass.
*Low intensity training (walking, easy cycling, light jogging, yoga, Pilates) will not require eating beforehand because your body can easily use stored fat at lower intensities for energy. Even if you haven’t eaten in 8-12 hours, you have plenty of stored glycogen (stored carbohydrate) to get you through a less intense workout. Your body won’t feel a deficit the way it would during HIIT or heavy lifting.
* Low intensity exercise doesn’t require explosive power. Your stored fat provides a steady energy supply. In a fasted state, insulin is low so your fat breakdown increases, and lighter workouts don’t stress the muscles heavily or elevate cortisol much, so the risk of muscle loss is minimal, even if you haven’t eaten.
* If you decide to exercise in a fed state, make sure that timing works with one of your regular meals and not an additional one. In the studies that showed similar fat loss and improved performance, it was when calories stayed the same – so it’s more a matter of timing of meals and exercise, not a matter of eating more for exercise. Exercise 1-3 hours after a meal you would have eaten anyway.
Schoenfeld, B. J., Aragon, A. A., et al. (2014). Body composition changes associated with fasted versus non-fasted aerobic exercise. Journal of the International Society of Sports Nutrition, 11(54). → Found no difference in fat loss over time between fasted and fed cardio.
Paoli, A. et al. (2011). Effects of early morning fasted vs. fed state aerobic exercise on fat loss. Journal of the International Society of Sports Nutrition. → Fasted exercise increases fat oxidation during the workout, but not total fat loss.
Horowitz, J. F. et al. (1999). Lipolytic and metabolic response to exercise in the fasted and fed states. Journal of Applied Physiology. → Fasted exercise increases fat use but may reduce performance in some individuals.
Mora-Rodriguez, R. & Ortega, J. F. (2019). Fasted training: metabolic adaptations and fat oxidation. Sports Medicine. → Reviews how fasted training affects metabolism and long-term adaptation.
Coyle, E. F. et al. (1985). Muscle glycogen utilization during prolonged exercise. Journal of Applied Physiology. → Fed training improves endurance and high-intensity performance.
Haff, G. & Triplett, N. (2015). Essentials of Strength Training and Conditioning. National Strength and Conditioning Association. → Strength training is generally better with some fuel present.